Methodology··7 min read

The Geology Sub-Score Is Four Numbers, Not One Resource Figure

A headline resource figure — "5.85 million ounces" — is a single number standing in for four separate judgments. MAS-Score's Geology sub-score, the single largest-weighted component in the overall score at 25%, is computed from grade, tonnage, deposit type, and reserve classification — and because those four inputs combine non-linearly, two deposits that look identical on their headline ounce count can score more than ten points apart, and the same deposit can score differently depending on which category of confidence its numbers are reported under.

The first two numbers: grade and tonnage aren't comparable on their own

Grade and tonnage each get converted to a 0–100 sub-component before anything else happens to them. Grade is scored against a ceiling that depends on deposit type — more on that below — and tonnage is scored on a deliberately non-linear scale: anything under 1 million tonnes scores 0, 1–5 Mt scores 40, 5–20 Mt scores 70, 20–100 Mt scores 85, and 100 Mt or more scores 100. The two are then blended 60% grade, 40% tonnage. The non-linearity matters: a deposit that grows from 20 Mt to 40 Mt gains nothing on the tonnage sub-component, because both fall in the same 20–100 Mt band, while a deposit that crosses from 4 Mt to 6 Mt jumps from a tonnage score of 40 to 70. Size alone, reported as a single ounce count, erases which side of those boundaries a company actually sits on.

The third input: deposit type sets the grade ceiling

Grade is not scored against a fixed scale — it is scored against a ceiling specific to how the deposit is mined. An underground gold deposit is scored against a 10 g/t ceiling, open-pit gold against 3 g/t, underground copper against 2.5%, and open-pit copper against 0.8%. The reason is mechanical, not arbitrary: high-cost underground mining only makes economic sense at grades that would be uneconomic to access by open pit, so the same 3 g/t that scores near the top of the open-pit ceiling scores only 30 out of 100 against the underground ceiling. A single "grade" field reported without the mining method behind it — the way most news coverage reports it — cannot be compared across companies at all; two companies both disclosing "3 g/t gold" can sit at opposite ends of the Geology sub-score depending on whether that grade comes from a pit or a shaft.

The fourth input: classification is a discount, not a label

The blended grade-and-tonnage score is then multiplied by a modifier that depends on how confidently the ounces are classified: 1.0x for Proven, Probable, or combined Proven-and-Probable reserves, 0.85x for a Measured-and-Indicated resource, and 0.5x for an Inferred resource. That ordering follows directly from the CIM Definition Standards for Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves, adopted by CIM Council on May 10, 2014 and incorporated by reference into NI 43-101: resources are sorted into Inferred, Indicated, and Measured by increasing geological confidence, Indicated can only convert to a Probable reserve, and Measured can convert to either a Proven or a Probable reserve[^2]. The standard goes further than MAS-Score's discount: it requires that Inferred Mineral Resources must not be included in the economic analysis, production schedule, or estimated mine life of a publicly disclosed pre-feasibility or feasibility study at all[^2]. MAS-Score's 0.5x is a penalty rather than an exclusion — a deliberate difference, since the Geology sub-score has to compare companies at every stage, including exploration-only juniors whose only disclosed ounces are Inferred.

A worked example: the same deposit, two classifications

Lundin Gold (TSX:LUG) — profiled in depth elsewhere on this blog — reported Proven and Probable Mineral Reserves for its Fruta del Norte deposit, an underground gold mine in Ecuador, of 23,154 kt (23.154 Mt) at 7.14 g/t Au as of December 31, 2025, disclosed in a news release dated February 17, 2026[^1]. Run through the formula above: a 7.14 g/t grade against the 10 g/t underground-gold ceiling scores 71.4; 23.154 Mt falls in the 20–100 Mt tonnage band, scoring 85; the blend is 0.6 × 71.4 + 0.4 × 85 = 76.84; and the Proven-and-Probable classification applies its 1.0x modifier, rounding to a Geology sub-score of 77. Report the identical grade and tonnage as a Measured-and-Indicated resource instead of a reserve — nothing about the rock itself changes, only the confidence category the company is entitled to disclose it under — and the 0.85x modifier drops the same calculation to 65. A twelve-point swing on MAS-Score's single largest-weighted sub-score, with no new assay and no change in tonnes.

What this means for coverage

The February 2026 release above gives the current reserve numbers, but it points back to the "Amended NI 43-101 Technical Report Fruta del Norte Mine Ecuador," dated March 29, 2023 with an effective date of December 31, 2022, for the methodology and Qualified Person sign-off behind them[^1]. That technical report is now nearly four years old — well past the 12-month window Mineralis treats as current — even though the reserve table it supports is updated annually by press release. The classification system itself (Inferred, Indicated, Measured, Probable, Proven) does not need to be re-filed every year to stay valid, but readers comparing "how fresh is this number" should know that a current-looking headline figure and the full technical report underneath it are not always the same age. Every citation MAS-Score attaches to a Geology sub-score traces to the specific document and page it came from — the same standard this blog has described for Qualified Person sign-off generally — precisely so that gap between a disclosure's headline date and its underlying technical report's effective date doesn't get silently inherited as evidence of currency it doesn't have. One data point from one Ecuadorian underground gold mine, reported under Canadian NI 43-101 rules, is not a claim about open-pit or copper deposits, or about deposits reported under other jurisdictions' classification regimes; it is one worked example of a mechanism that applies to all four.

References

  1. Lundin Gold Inc., "Lundin Gold Reports Record Mineral Reserves and Expands the FDN District with FDNS Reserve and FDN East Inferred Resource," news release dated February 17, 2026. Mineral Reserve and Resource tables effective December 31, 2025. The release states that additional information on the estimates is contained in the "Amended NI 43-101 Technical Report Fruta del Norte Mine Ecuador," dated March 29, 2023 (effective December 31, 2022), filed under the company's profile on SEDAR+. Scope: a single underground-gold deposit (Fruta del Norte, Ecuador); the governing technical report is nearly four years old relative to this post's publication date.
  2. Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM), "CIM Definition Standards for Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves," adopted by CIM Council, May 10, 2014. Incorporated by reference into National Instrument 43-101. Scope: Canadian standard governing resource/reserve classification categories; no newer edition identified as of this writing.

Request beta access.

Mineralis is currently in Private Beta. Family offices, independent analysts, and mining investors are being invited in waves.

Join the beta waitlist →

More from the blog

← Back to blog