Methodology··7 min read

The Management Sub-Score Is Four Numbers, Not a Resume

MAS-Score's Management sub-score (15% weight, same as Capital and Jurisdiction) does not read a CEO's biography and form an impression. It adds four measured components — tenure in the role, insider holding percentage, the independent fraction of the board, and a categorical read of the team's past discovery record — each traced to a specific disclosure. Run the same formula against four actual gold producers and the result is not a ranking of reputations; it is a ranking of what each company's own filings disclose about alignment and continuity.

Four components, not a vibe

The formula is deliberately mechanical. CEO tenure contributes up to 30 points: 30 at seven years or more in the role, 20 at four to six, 10 at two to three, 0 below that. Insider holding contributes up to 30: 30 at 5% of shares outstanding or more, 25 at 3% or more, 15 at 1% or more, and a floor of 5 below that — the component never reaches zero, because a public company with literally no insider ownership disclosed is a rare and separately notable fact, not the typical bottom case. Board independence contributes up to 20: 20 once two-thirds or more of the board is independent, 15 at a bare majority, 5 below that. A categorical read of the team's past discovery record — high, medium, low, or none — contributes the final 20. Add them up, clamp to 0–100, and that is the sub-score; there is no fifth input that quietly overrides the other four.

Tenure and independence come from the same document

A CEO's start date is not a research project — it is a disclosed fact in every proxy statement's officer biography, filed under Item 401 of SEC Regulation S-K for U.S. registrants and under the equivalent director-and-officer disclosure in a Canadian issuer's management information circular. (Item 401's companion clause, 401(f), is what forces disclosure of a named officer's regulatory history — we covered that mechanism in a separate piece on promotional risk.) Board independence is equally checkable, just against a different instrument: U.S. exchanges require it structurally — the NYSE's majority-independent-board standard, Section 303A.01 of the Listed Company Manual, was approved by the SEC in Release No. 34-47672 in November 2003, with existing listed companies required to comply no later than 18 months after that approval[^1]. Canadian issuers disclose the same fact under National Policy 58-201, Corporate Governance Guidelines, and National Instrument 58-101, Disclosure of Corporate Governance Practices, both in force since June 30, 2005[^2]. Neither jurisdiction leaves "how independent is this board" to inference from tone.

The same percentage means something different at a major than at a junior

Run the formula against four producers and the insider-holding component splits them into two groups that have nothing to do with how trustworthy each management team is. Lundin Gold's (TSX:LUG) 2024 management information circular discloses CEO Ron Hochstein in the role since 2017 — seven years as of the 2024-Q3 measurement, the maximum tenure tier — alongside insider holdings of 4.2%, scoring 25 of 30 on that component, and a board that is 66% independent, the maximum tier on that component too[^3]. Agnico Eagle's (NYSE:AEM) 2024 proxy shows CEO Ammar Al-Joundi in the role since 2015 (30 of 30 on tenure), insider holdings of 1.1% (15 of 30), and an 83% independent board (20 of 20)[^3]. Combined with a discovery-record read of "high" for both, the formula scores Lundin Gold 95 and Agnico Eagle 85.

Newmont (NYSE:NEM) and Barrick (NYSE:B) land at 57 each — not because their executives are less credible, but because their insider-holding component hits the 5-point floor. Newmont's 2024 proxy discloses CEO Tom Palmer's holdings at roughly 0.3% of shares outstanding; Barrick's 2024 management circular discloses CEO Mark Bristow's at roughly 0.5%[^3]. Both are read from a U.S. beneficial-ownership table under Item 403 of Regulation S-K for Newmont, and from Canadian insider filings through SEDI for Barrick, which remains Canadian-domiciled despite its NYSE listing[^4]. At a roughly $50 billion market capitalization, a CEO personally holding even 1% would be a half-billion-dollar stake — the percentage test that discriminates meaningfully among juniors, where a founder or promoter's stake is genuinely discretionary, compresses almost every senior producer's management team into the same floor. The component is doing its job; it is just answering a question that matters far more at the small end of the market it was built to cover.

The one soft input, and why its absence isn't scored as failure

Tenure, holding, and independence all come from a bright-line disclosure item with a number or a date attached. Past discovery record does not — no filing anywhere requires a management team to characterize its own exploration history as "high," "medium," "low," or "none," so the input is a judgment call made against the filings' narrative, and it is the one component in the formula marked optional. When it is absent, the engine does not default it to "none" — that would convert a missing sentence in a proxy into a 20-point penalty for something that was never actually measured. Instead the three known components are rescaled proportionally across the full 100 points, the same fail-closed instinct behind the Numbers-Guard and behind how Promotional Risk treats a SEDI-only issuer's missing insider data: an unmeasured input is not quietly scored as a clean one.

A check the formula doesn't price in yet: related-party transactions

None of the four components asks whether management is transacting with the company it runs — a director selling a property into the issuer, or a private placement priced to an insider below market. Two disclosure regimes exist specifically to surface that: Item 404(a) of Regulation S-K requires a U.S. registrant to disclose any related-person transaction since the start of the last fiscal year exceeding $120,000 (or, for a smaller reporting company, the lesser of $120,000 or 1% of average total assets over the last two fiscal years)[^5]. Canada's Multilateral Instrument 61-101, Protection of Minority Security Holders in Special Transactions, goes further for TSX-listed issuers — requiring enhanced disclosure, an independent formal valuation, and minority-shareholder approval for certain related-party transactions; it has been in force in Ontario and Quebec since February 1, 2008, and was extended to Alberta, Manitoba, and New Brunswick on July 31, 2017[^6]. Both are real, checkable filings an analyst can pull today. Neither currently feeds the Management sub-score, and that gap is worth stating plainly rather than leaving a reader to assume the four components are the whole picture.

What this means for verifying coverage

Three of the four Management components can be checked by anyone with the right filing open: a CEO's start date from the proxy biography, the independent fraction of the board from the same document's governance disclosure, and insider holdings from a Item 403 ownership table or, for a Canadian issuer, SEDI. The fourth — discovery record — is inherently a judgment call, which is exactly why its absence should never be read the same as a documented failure. Mineralis extracts all four as structured inputs from each company's own proxy or management circular rather than leaving an analyst to re-derive them filing by filing, and flags the related-party-transaction gap as a roadmap item rather than pretending the current formula already covers it.

References

  1. New York Stock Exchange, Listed Company Manual, Section 303A.01 (majority-independent board); U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Release No. 34-47672, approving the NYSE's corporate-governance listing standards, November 2003, requiring existing listed companies to comply no later than 18 months after approval. Scope: NYSE-listed issuers.
  2. Canadian Securities Administrators, National Policy 58-201 — Corporate Governance Guidelines, and National Instrument 58-101 — Disclosure of Corporate Governance Practices, both in force since June 30, 2005. Scope: Canadian reporting issuers other than investment funds; guidance, not a prescriptive minimum-independence rule.
  3. Mineralis internal ingestion of each company's 2024 management information circular or proxy statement: Lundin Gold (TSX:LUG, asOf 2024-Q3) — CEO Ron Hochstein since 2017, insider holdings 4.2% per SEDAR insider filings, board independence 66%; Agnico Eagle (NYSE:AEM, asOf 2024-Q4) — CEO Ammar Al-Joundi since 2015, insider holdings approximately 1.1%, board independence 83%. Scope: these two companies only, not a statement about management quality across the covered universe.
  4. Mineralis internal ingestion of each company's 2024 proxy statement or management circular: Newmont (NYSE:NEM, asOf 2024-Q4) — CEO Tom Palmer since 2019, insider holdings approximately 0.3% per the proxy's Item 403 beneficial-ownership table; Barrick (NYSE:B, formerly NYSE:GOLD until May 2025, asOf 2024-Q4) — CEO Mark Bristow since 2019, insider holdings approximately 0.5% per Canadian insider filings. Scope: these two companies only.
  5. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Regulation S-K Item 404(a) (related person transactions), $120,000 disclosure threshold (the lesser of $120,000 or 1% of average total assets over the last two completed fiscal years for a smaller reporting company). Scope: SEC registrants filing a proxy statement or annual report.
  6. Canadian Securities Administrators, Multilateral Instrument 61-101 — Protection of Minority Security Holders in Special Transactions, in force in Ontario and Quebec since February 1, 2008, extended to Alberta, Manitoba, and New Brunswick effective July 31, 2017. Scope: reporting issuers in the adopting provinces; TSX and TSX-V issuers outside those provinces may still be bound through exchange policy.

Request beta access.

Mineralis is currently in Private Beta. Family offices, independent analysts, and mining investors are being invited in waves.

Join the beta waitlist →

More from the blog

← Back to blog