The Permitting Sub-Score Is Three Numbers, Not a Status Label
A U.S. government review of 68 approved hardrock mine plans found that agency review time ranged from about one month to more than eleven years, averaging roughly two years[^1]. "Permits secured" is a single word covering outcomes two orders of magnitude apart in elapsed time. MAS-Score's Permitting sub-score does not score that word. It scores three separate numbers underneath it — a project's current status, the jurisdiction it sits in, and its own track record against its original timeline.
What a status field hides
Every mining company discloses a permitting status in some form — a line in the MD&A, a slide in a corporate deck, a paragraph in the NI 43-101 technical report's permitting section. That status is almost always one of a handful of categories: permits fully secured, partially secured, in progress, not yet started, or actively contested. It is a true snapshot of where a project stands today. What it cannot tell you is how it got there, how fast it is likely to keep moving, or how far outside the normal range its own history already sits. Two projects can carry the identical "in-progress" label while one clears its remaining approvals within a quarter and the other has already run three times over its original schedule.
The three numbers behind the label
MAS-Score's engine maps the status label onto a base value first: all-secured scores 95, partially-secured 70, in-progress 50, not-started 30, and contested 10 — contested status is treated as the worst state a permitting process can be in, below even a project that has not applied for anything yet. A second number, a jurisdiction-stability flag, then adds 5 points in a stable jurisdiction or subtracts 15 in an unstable one, because the same status carries different forward risk depending on where the project sits. The third number is specific to the project itself: a timeline-overrun factor comparing actual elapsed time against the schedule the company originally disclosed. Below 1.1x there is no penalty — normal slippage is not punished. Above that, the penalty steps up in three tiers: 10 points at 1.1–1.5x the original timeline, 20 points at 1.5–2.0x, and 30 points beyond 2.0x. The scale only penalizes lateness; finishing early is rare enough across the industry that the engine does not reward it. All three numbers combine into a single 0-100 value that carries a 10% weight in the overall MAS-Score.
Why the average hides more than it shows
The U.S. Government Accountability Office reviewed 68 hardrock mine plans of operations that the Bureau of Land Management and the U.S. Forest Service approved across fiscal years 2010 through 2014, drawing on interviews in 23 offices spanning the 12 western states where hardrock mining occurs[^1]. Its finding: review time for an approved plan ranged from about one month to more than eleven years, averaging approximately two years — with officials citing the low quality of operator-submitted mine plans and agencies' limited staffing for hardrock programs as the two most common causes of delay. That range is the entire point of scoring a timeline-overrun factor separately from a status label. A company that discloses "in-progress" after one month and a company that discloses the same word after eleven years are, on this data, both inside the historical distribution — but they are not remotely the same risk, and a label with no elapsed-time context cannot tell them apart.
What the contested tail actually looks like
Alaska's Pebble deposit shows what the bottom of the status scale costs in practice. Pebble Limited Partnership filed its Clean Water Act Section 404 permit application with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' Alaska District on December 22, 2017[^2]. The Corps issued a Record of Decision denying that permit on November 25, 2020 — just over three years later — finding the project not in the public interest[^2]. Rather than closing the file, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency then invoked its rarely used Clean Water Act Section 404(c) authority, issuing a Final Determination on January 30, 2023 that prohibits using certain Bristol Bay watershed waters as disposal sites for the project's dredged or fill material — a sweeping, site-specific veto rather than an ordinary permit denial[^3]. On appeal, the Corps' Pacific Ocean Division ultimately upheld the original denial in 2024. Every status this project has carried since late 2017 has been some form of "contested" — the engine's floor value of 10 — and more than six years of elapsed time has not moved it off that floor. A timeline-overrun factor computed against Pebble's original permitting schedule would, at this point, sit well past the engine's steepest 30-point penalty tier.
What this means for coverage
Permitting (10% weight) is deliberately narrower than the Jurisdiction sub-score (15% weight) that sits next to it. Jurisdiction scores the average regulatory environment a company operates in, rebased from the Fraser Institute's Policy Perception Index; Permitting scores one specific project's own documented status, stability context, and track record — the project-level layer that piece described but didn't score. Neither number substitutes for reading the permitting section of a company's own NI 43-101 technical report or the latest MD&A disclosure — the sub-score is a structured starting point for that reading, not a replacement for it. A "contested" label by itself tells an analyst almost nothing about how long a project has been stuck there; the number behind the label does.
References
- U.S. Government Accountability Office, Hardrock Mining: BLM and Forest Service Have Taken Some Actions to Expedite the Mine Plan Review Process but Could Do More, GAO-16-165, published January 2016. Scope: 68 hardrock mine plans of operations approved by the Bureau of Land Management and U.S. Forest Service, drawn from data for fiscal years 2010 through 2014 and interviews across 23 offices in the 12 western states where hardrock mining occurs on federal land; not a global or cross-commodity statistic. Field period note: the underlying review data is from fiscal years 2010–2014 — more than a decade old at the time of writing — and is the most recent GAO study of its kind located for this piece; more recent (2025–2026) U.S. permitting- reform claims circulating in trade press were not used here because none supplied a comparably transparent dataset or methodology.
- U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Alaska District, permit file POA-2017-271 (Pebble Limited Partnership), application filed December 22, 2017; Record of Decision denying the Clean Water Act Section 404 permit issued November 25, 2020. Scope: a single project, the Pebble deposit, southwest Alaska; not a statement about Alaska or U.S. permitting generally.
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Final Determination Pursuant to Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act, Pebble Deposit Area, Southwest Alaska, issued January 30, 2023. Scope: the Bristol Bay watershed waters tied to the Pebble deposit specifically; this is a site-specific determination, not a general EPA mining policy.
Request beta access.
Mineralis is currently in Private Beta. Family offices, independent analysts, and mining investors are being invited in waves.
Join the beta waitlist →